Pros: Overall quality, softness of the leather. Love the more rugged soles.
Cons: WAY too large in the instep. A bit clunky looking. Zipper on the left boot was a bit dicey.
Comments: These are nice, soft leather boots, especially for the price. The shaft fit my calf well and they were relatively nice to walk in. Foot size as far as length and width across the ball of the foot was accurate. However, the instep is oversized and bulky. I have skinny feet, but I've not even had this issue in casual boots so didn't anticipate a problem. Thick socks wouldn't help as then the foot would be tight but you'd still have extra space on top of your foot. Had to return them as I wasn't pleased with the fit in the foot.